A Few of my Favorite Themes
I think there are themes that we as readers—and writers—return to again and again. Storylines that speak to us as individuals, that touch a chord within our hearts and show us new truths about old pains.
I have a few favorites themes I revisit often, both as a reader and writer. I bet you have favorites, too. So, I’ll share mine if you’ll share yours.
1. The redemption story
I love redemption stories. The idea that we can change, improve and overcome is such an appealing thing to me. One of my favorite characters on TV these days is James “Sawyer” Ford on the ABC drama LOST. In the first two seasons, Sawyer was a cross between a villain and a trickster, a rough, dark, often unpleasant character determined to look out for himself and his wants and needs, even at the sacrifice of everyone around him. But over the course of the series, he has evolved into a man able to make emotional connections with others, to look out for the well-being of his friends. He hasn’t lost his edge; he’s moody, irritable, sometimes selfish and often quick to anger, but he’s still hero material, as he proved for most of last season.
In one of my books, COWBOY ALIBI, it was the heroine who needed redemption. A combination of a troubled upbringing and a series of foolish mistakes has led her to a place where she lied more than she told the truth. But when her memory is wiped clean after a trauma, the woman who now knows herself as Jane Doe has the chance to remake herself, to start fresh—but not before she faces her past.
Which brings us to…
2. Facing the past
In one way or another, almost all of my characters have to face their pasts in some way, come to terms with something that’s been haunting them for years. This is especially true in my new Cooper Justice series from Harlequin Intrigue. In this month’s Cooper Justice book, CHICKASAW COUNTY CAPTIVE, Kristen Tandy has to face a tragic crime perpetrated on herself and her deceased brothers and sisters by her mother. It’s the kind of horror tale that most people would have trouble surviving emotionally, and Kristen is no exception. But as a police detective, she has to overcome the fears her past has wrought in order to protect a young child in danger.
Kristen’s initial instinct is to let someone else take over the job of protecting young Maddy. But Maddy has chosen Kristen to protect her, which forces Kristen to deal with her phobias and come to terms with her past as well as what she wants from the future.
3. The reluctant hero
Speaking of characters whose initial instinct is to avoid getting involved, another theme I love is the reluctant hero. I think this particular theme resonates with me because I see myself as radically ordinary. I don’t have a lot of exciting skills or captivating experiences in my life. I’m just a nice, middle class woman from the South who works as a graphic designer and writes books. I’m scared of heights, shy around strangers and prone to hermit-like behavior. But I still like to believe I’d step up to the plate in a crisis and do what it takes to help people survive.
Some of the heroes and heroines in my books are reluctant to get involved at first. Maddox Heller, the hero of FORBIDDEN TOUCH, doesn’t think he has what it takes to help out Iris, the heroine, when her friend goes missing. He’s tried playing hero before and it ended badly on a lot of different levels. But when it’s clear Iris needs protection, Maddox can’t let her try to go it alone. And in the process of helping Iris get to the bottom of the mystery of her missing friend, Maddox rediscovers his inner strength and his desire to do good in the world.
4. Stranger in a strange land
Finally, a favorite theme I’ve explored in several books is the hero or heroine thrust into an alien situation and forced to figure his or her way on instinct—and with the help of the person who turns out to be his or her soul mate. In my January 2010 Intrigue, CASE FILE: CANYON CREEK, WYOMING, Hannah Cooper is literally a stranger in town, a tourist driving through western Wyoming on her way to visit the state parks, when she’s attacked by a would-be killer. When she escapes, making her the only living survivor of a serial killer Riley Patterson has been hunting for three long years, she becomes a person of extreme interest to Riley. I put an Alabama girl, a fishing guide, in the heart of Wyoming ranch country, targeted by a killer she can’t remember or identify except in snippets and flashes of memory. I give her a protector still in love with his dead wife and driven to find a killer at almost any cost. There’s inherent drama in being thrust into unfamiliar, high stakes situations.
There you go. A few of my favorite themes. What about you? What story themes do you enjoy in the romances you read or write?
Don’t forget my books Case File: Canyon Creek, Wyoming and Chickasaw County Captive are still available at most online book outlets. Visit my website at http://www.paulagraves.com/ or my blog, spinstersandlunatics.blogspot.com, to keep up with my current and future projects.
by Guest Chef
15 comments
Good morning Paula,
I’ve written adoption into a couple of my books. I’m not adopted, nor have I adopted, but I just feel so strongly about kids without families to love them.
I also write strong, overcoming females…regardless of the situation.
Thanks for blogging with us today.
Sandy
Sandra, that sounds like a wonderful theme. As the sister of an adoptee and the aunt of two adoptees, it’s a subject very close to my heart.
And if you love strong, overcoming families, you might like the Cooper family, the stars of my current Intrigue series, Cooper Justice. They’re a boisterous, hard-fighting, tough-loving family who attract danger like bees to nectar. My January and February books introduced two of them, Hannah Cooper and her brother Sam, and two more books out in August and September of this year feature Cooper brothers Luke and Aaron, each in his own story.
Hello Paula,
I really enjoyed your post. I liked the way you categorized the themes we’ve all come to love.
I adore reading about a tortured hero. I can’t get enough of those characters. I like heroes that are scarred emotionally somehow, I like them to be irascible, not mean, but surly at first. A true alpha on the outside, with the gentle heart of a beta.
Like Sandy, I tend to write strong willed female leads. I like my heroines to tame the savage beast!
I also really liked the way you described yourself. You sound like a great person and your books sound compelling too.
Thanks for blogging with us today.
Have a fabulous Wednesday,
Tamara
Thanks for blogging with us. I loved your post and learned a lot.
Your books sound really good.
I’m using redemption as the theme in my current work in progress.
Marilyn
Hi Paula -
Wonderful way you broke out the different themes. Intrique and SRS will always be two of my favorite category lines. Congratulations on your success in series – I meet a lot of readers who are long time fans of Intrigue, which is easy to understand.
Thanks, y’all! Tamara, thanks for the kind words about me. I hope I’m likable!
And your description of a hero is exactly what I like. I call them Betas in Alpha clothing, though that’s not really fair. They’re not betas–they’re tough and assertive and very, very masculine and challenging, but they’re not mean or dictatorial, and they love a woman who’ll give as good as she gets.
Marilyn, redemption is a theme as old as time, and it never, ever gets old because we all need redemption from time to time, being fallible humans. I think everyone can relate.
Thanks, Dianna! I’ve been watching your own career take off since your first sale, and I’m so impressed.
Hi Paula, thanks for being our guest chef today.
I really enjoyed your description of the various themes you like to write – all of which I like to read.
I’m particularly intrigued (pardon the pun ) by your January release: Case File: Canyon Creek Wyoming. I’m going to have to go find a copy.
I’d have to say right now my recurrent themes are redemption and belonging.
Thanks again for being here.
Great post, Paula! I, too, like redemption stories–I am a sucker for tortured souls. My other favorite theme is the coming home story–I love to read and write stories about heroes and heroines who come home. Of course, coming home stories usually involve facing the past.
Another of my favorites is the marriage of convenience. Whether it’s a Regency or a modern marriage sham, I love that particular convention.
Thanks for sharing your experiences with us and I look forward to reading your books!
Ooh, those are some of my favorite themes. Belonging crops up frequently in my work. I enjoy reading books with intrigue!
Thanks for being with us today, Paula. I had never really thought in terms of the themes I gravitate toward. I too like redemption stories and stories about ordinary people doing extraordinary things — or at least finding the one thing they do best, and using it to improve the lives of others. I like a little mystery in most things that I read and write, and I also have a tendency toward including romantic triangles in my writing.
I will definitely have to look for your books; sounds like they contain all the elements I enjoy!
I’m definitely stuck on redemption stories and facing your past. I’m working on a story I hope to sell to HQ Intrigue and it is definitely a facing your past type of tale. I really liked the way you handled that in Chickasaw County Captive. Kristen’s past is a dramatic one and well-woven into the suspense. In my opinion it was a challenging past to weave into an Intrigue and you did it well enough that it retained its emotional depth.
Thanks, Debbie. I agree–it was a pretty bleak backstory, and hard to deal with in such a short word count, but when the character of Kristen introduced herself to me, I couldn’t stop thinking about her until I told her story.
Sally, I loved Marriage of Convenience stories, too. I blogged about that a couple of months ago on the Intrigue Authors blog on eHarlequin. I’m still trying to figure out a good M of C story idea for Intrigue, but its a little harder in that subgenre than in others.
Darcy, please let me know what you think of Case File: Canyon Creek, Wyoming if you read it. Normally, I don’t read my own books after they’re in print (I’m afraid I’ll see a bunch of errors or typos that will haunt me incessantly), but for some reason I read CF:CCW. I had my own thoughts about what I did right and what I wish I’d done better. I’d love to hear your take on it.
Carol, belonging is a great theme–it’s so universal, since we’re all trying to figure out where we belong and to whom or what we belong.
EC, there’s something of a triangle in Case File: Canyon Creek, Wyoming. Of course, one of the three is dead…but…
Hi Paula!
Great post. I love many different themes and you (and all the other commentors) touched on most of them.
My favorite (I think) is the savior of the world theme. You know the one where the hero/heroine is destined to save the world but doesn’t know it. (ex. Harry Potter, Percy Jackson)
I also LOVE most story lines that connect to Greek mythology, the Egyptian pyramids, the Bermuda triangle and other fable-myth-historical-like tales. Love, love, love those.
I will tell you a theme I don’t like and that is the secret baby theme. I know a lot of people LOVE that theme and I am so not faulting them for it. It’s just that I’ve seen the fallout of one of those in real life and it really turned me against those.
Thanks for making us think about this. I hadn’t for quite a while and I think I have a new story brewing…grin…
Tami
PS – I’m originally from Wyoming and I can’t wait to read your Wyoming book. Oh yeah, another love is stories set in specific areas. See, more ideas brewing…grin….
Tami, if you don’t like secret baby stories, don’t read my August book. Although, honestly, I totally get where you’re coming from. I don’t like them, either, as a rule, and I worked really, really hard to establish why the baby was kept secret. Both parties had good, understandable reasons for their actions. I’d honestly be interested to have people who don’t like that kind of story give my book a chance anyway, because I want to know if you think I managed to walk the very fine line between such a story working and not working.
You know, I didn’t actually set out to write a secret baby story when I first conceived of the plot. The heroine’s baby wasn’t the hero’s in the beginning. But as I was working out the plot, I realized that the conflict would be so much more compelling and the stakes twice as high, if the baby was the hero’s. Trust me, I cursed when I realized that fact! But it’s what the story was demanding, so I sat down and pondered all my own issues with the idea and looked at whether or not I could address them in a way that would satisfy myself as a critic. I hope I succeeded with other critics of that kind of storyline as well.
I swore when I decided I wanted to write for category that I wouldn’t write cowboys, secret babies or runaway brides.
All that’s left is to write a runaway bride and I’ll have broken all those vows.
Hey Paula,
I just popped over to Amazon and bought your Case File: Canyon Creek for my computer. I can’t wait to read that one.
I couldn’t find a blurb on your August book, One Tough Marine (it said the link was broken on your website and there’s no blurb yet on Amazon); but I will definitely give it a read. I went ahead and added it to my wish list on Amazon. It sounds like you put a lot of thought into making it work and I am more than willing to give it a read and let you know what I think.
Thanks for the heads-up on it.
Tami
Ps – Love your website.